Rigor in Theory Building from Multiple Cases

Authored by: Kathleen M. Eisenhardt , Timothy E. Ott

The Routledge Companion to Qualitative Research in Organization Studies

Print publication date:  September  2017
Online publication date:  August  2017

Print ISBN: 9781138921948
eBook ISBN: 9781315686103
Adobe ISBN:

10.4324/9781315686103.ch6

 Download Chapter

 

Abstract

Theory building from multiple cases has generated some of the most cited and intriguing research over the last 80 years. Yet there remains confusion regarding how to judge its rigor. We begin with a short history and description of the method including replication logic. We then focus on four central criteria for rigor: The first is strong emergent theory – i.e., theory that is accurate, internally coherent and parsimonious. Such theory usually includes clear constructs and logical underlying arguments for relating them as well as sensitivity to boundary conditions and alternative explanations. The second is compelling evidence that starts with deep immersion in rich data from multiple sources and informants, and uses “construct tables” to analyze and display data. The third is theoretical sampling and research designs that involve careful selection of cases using research designs that provide a sharp focus on the phenomena of interest. The fourth is an intriguing research question that often emphasizes processes, centers on either similarity or variance, and emerges from a precise reading of literature. We briefly note that rigor is not based on superficial criteria like narrow writing formats, rigid rules for data analysis, and exhaustive details of the method. We conclude that rigor in theory building from multiple cases rests on the same few core criteria that characterize, in a broad sense, most if not all rigorous research.

 Cite
Search for more...
Back to top

Use of cookies on this website

We are using cookies to provide statistics that help us give you the best experience of our site. You can find out more in our Privacy Policy. By continuing to use the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.